Plan of Attack - 2 Back
By Bob Woodward
Washington Post Staff Writer
Blair Steady in Support
'I'm There to the Very End,' Prime Minister Told Bush
On Sunday, March 9, 2003 -- 10 days before launching war with
Iraq -- President Bush was increasingly worried about the
political peril of his chief ally, British Prime Minister Tony
Blair.
"Do you think he could lose his government?" Bush asked
Condoleezza Rice, his national security adviser.
"Yes," she replied.
"Would the British really do that?"
"Remember Churchill," she said, noting that he had lost
his government after winning World War II. Though Blair's Labor
Party had more than a 2 to 1 majority in Parliament, the
defection of 150 or more Laborites would leave the opposition
Conservatives with the temptation or opportunity to join the
Labor defectors to bring down Blair's government in a vote of no
confidence.
The president was very worried. He called Blair for one of their
regular conversations. They explored the possibilities, which
other countries on the U.N. Security Council they could get to
support or at least acquiesce in a war. His last choice, said
Bush, would be "to have your government go down. We don't
want that to happen under any circumstances. I really mean
that."
If it would help, Bush said, he would let Blair drop out of the
coalition and they would find some other way for Britain and its
41,000 military personnel in the region around Iraq to
participate.
"I said I'm with you. I mean it," Blair replied.
Bush said they could think of another role for the British forces
-- "a second wave, peacekeepers or something. I would rather
go alone than have your government fall."
"I understand that," Blair responded, "and that's
good of you to say. I said, I'm with you."
Bush said he really meant that it would be all right for Blair to
opt out. "You can bank on that."
"I know you do," Blair said, "and I appreciate
that. I absolutely believe in this, too. Thank you. I appreciate
that. It's good of you to say that," the prime minister
repeated in his very British way. "But I'm there to the very
end."
It was an extraordinary offer, confirmed by Bush in an interview
in December. Had Blair accepted, the United States would have
been virtually alone in launching the war -- with only a few
thousand troops from countries such as Australia and Poland.
Blair Pushes U.N. Route
On the morning of Sept. 7, 2002, Blair left London on a
transatlantic flight to see Bush at Camp David. The president had
invited him to come for dinner and a three-hour talk on Iraq.
Blair would be on the ground for about six hours -- an unusually
short stay.
In Blair's conversations with Bush, it was increasingly clear to
the prime minister how committed Bush was to action. But as
Blair's foreign secretary, Jack Straw, had signaled to his
counterpart, Secretary of State Colin L. Powell, in a meeting the
month before, the message from the British in essence was: If you
are really thinking about war and you want us to be a player, we
cannot be unless you go to the United Nations. Powell also
favored a U.N. resolution, and he knew this would add to the
pressure on Bush, who absolutely had to have Blair on board.
Blair's style was to have ongoing debates with himself and his
small circle of advisers, testing, searching, "weighing
things up," as one of his advisers said. On Iraq, Blair had
traveled several roads. "Look, if Bush hadn't been exercised
after 9/11 about these issues," he told his advisers several
times, "I would have been worrying about them, and I raised
them with him before 9/11." The issues were terrorism,
weapons of mass destruction and Iraq. For years, Blair had warned
about the threat posed by Saddam Hussein.
Of the three countries Bush cited
as constituting the "axis of evil," Blair was most
worried about North Korea, and he believed Iran was close to
developing dangerous WMD stockpiles. Iraq was at the bottom of
the list for the prime minister, one adviser said, suggesting
Blair was not at this point as driven about Hussein as Bush.
"Iraq is an American question," that adviser added.
"It's not a British question. And it couldn't be anybody
else's because no one else had the capability." Britain was
not setting the military agenda, needless to say. It was out of
the question that Britain would ever go it alone. "We
couldn't have invaded Iraq."
Blair was keenly aware that in Britain the question was: Does
Blair believe in the United Nations? It was critical domestically
for the prime minister to show his own Labor Party, a pacifist
party at heart, opposed to war in principle, that he had gone the
U.N. route. Public opinion in Britain favored trying to make
international institutions work before resorting to force. Going
through the United Nations would be a large and much-needed plus.
After taking questions from reporters, the two leaders, with Vice
President Cheney in attendance, sat down for a private talk.
There was no specific war planning. The issue was political
strategy.
Blair said he had to be able to show that he had tried the United
Nations and sought a new resolution requiring the readmission of
weapons inspectors inside Iraq. "He's there to make the case
for a resolution," Bush recalled in an interview in
December. He told Blair he had decided to go to the United
Nations, and it seemed he would seek a new resolution.
Blair was relieved.
Bush looked Blair in the eye. "Saddam Hussein is a threat.
And we must work together to deal with this threat, and the world
will be better off without him." Bush recalled that he was
"probing" and "pushing" the prime minister.
He said it might require -- would probably entail -- war. Blair
might have to send British troops.
"I'm with you," the prime minister replied, looking
Bush back in the eye, pledging flat out to commit British
military force if necessary, the critical promise Bush had been
seeking.
"We want you to be part of this," he told the prime
minister. Blair's resolve had made a real impression, the
president later recalled.
After the meeting, Bush walked into the conference room where
Alastair Campbell, the prime minister's communications director,
and several other Blair aides were waiting.
"Your man has got cojones," the president said, using a
colloquial Spanish term for courage.
The president recalled, "And of course these Brits don't
know what cojones are." He said he would call the Camp David
session with Blair "the cojones meeting."
As a practical matter, by agreeing to the urging of Blair and
Powell to go to the United Nations to seek a new resolution, Bush
had improved his position immeasurably. It meant that no matter
what happened, as long as Blair kept his word, he would not have
to go it alone.
An Absolute Political Necessity
Two months later, the U.N. Security Council passed Resolution
1441 unanimously, 15 to 0, requiring new weapons inspections and
declaring that if Hussein continued to violate his disarmament
obligations, he would face "serious consequences."
The U.N. inspectors went into Iraq, but Bush became frustrated
and angry at their lack of progress. In early January 2003, the
president secretly decided on war, but he continued to pursue a
diplomatic solution publicly.
On Jan. 31, 2003, Bush was scheduled to meet again with Blair at
Camp David, but a mix of rain and ice kept them at the White
House. Blair told Bush that he needed to get a second U.N.
resolution. He had promised that to his party at home, and he was
confident that together he and Bush could rally the United
Nations and the international community.
Bush was set against a second
resolution. So were Cheney and Powell -- a rare case in which
they agreed. The first resolution had taken seven weeks, and this
one would be much harder. But Blair had the winning argument. It
was necessary for him politically. It was no more complicated
than that, an absolute political necessity. Blair said he needed
the favor. Please.
That was language Bush understood. "If that's what you need,
we will go flat out to try and help you get it," he told
Blair. He also didn't want to go alone, and without Britain he
would be close to going alone.
"Blair's got to deal with his own Parliament, his own
people, but he has to deal with the French-British relationship
as well, and its context within Europe," Bush said later.
"And so he's got a very difficult assignment. Much more
difficult, by the way, than the American president in some ways.
This was the period where slowly but surely the French became the
issue inside Britain."
Bush called it "the famous second-resolution meeting"
and said Blair "absolutely" asked for help. The new
resolution, which would declare that Hussein had "failed
to" comply, was introduced in late February, but the efforts
to get other Security Council members to sign on floundered.
Pleading for Votes
On March 12, three days after he had declined Bush's offer for
Britain to not use its troops in combat, Blair called Bush for an
update on where things stood in the Security Council.
"If we don't have the votes," Bush said, "pull it
down. We're through." He had had it with the resolutions.
"Would you try one more time?" Blair asked, referring
to the key votes of Mexican President Vicente Fox and Chilean
President Ricardo Lagos.
"Of course," Bush said. "I'd be glad to do
that."
Bush called Fox. "Vicente, I'm insisting there be a vote
tomorrow in the U.N. Can we count on your vote?"
"Exactly what's the language like in the resolution?"
Fox asked.
"Vicente, we've debated this issue long enough. The security
of the United States is on the line. I want your vote."
Fox said he would get back to Bush. Later, during dinner, Rice
called Bush to say she had received a phone call saying that Luis
Ernesto Derbez, Mexico's foreign minister, was now in charge of
the Mexican policy because Fox had to go into the hospital for
back surgery.
"Interesting," Bush said. He called Lagos -- a
distinguished leader in Bush's view, so he was polite. No
threats.
"Can we count on your vote?" Bush asked the 65-year-old
Socialist leader.
"Are you sure it's time to bring up the vote?"
"But we're making
progress," Lagos replied.
"That's only because we've got a couple of hundred thousand
troops. If those troops weren't there, there'd be even less
progress diplomatically. And Saddam Hussein could care less. Any
progress you think is being made is illusionary." Bush then
stated his predicament clearly. "And I'm not going to leave
our troops there. They're either going to go in, and remove him,
or they're coming home, Ricardo."
This was a sobering thought. For both practical and political
reasons, bringing the troops home without solving the Hussein
problem was unthinkable for Bush. It was similar to the position
his father had found himself in during January 1991 with 500,000
military men and women in the Middle East. "We have to have
a war," President George H.W. Bush had told his advisers
several weeks before launching the 1991 Persian Gulf War. Once
again a President Bush, this time with more than 200,000 troops
in the Middle East, had put himself into the position where he
had to have a war.
Bush asked Lagos, "Ricardo, what's your vote?"
No, the Chilean president replied.
"Thank you very much," Bush said.
Bush called Blair and described his talks with Fox and Lagos.
"You have to consider these two conversations," Bush
said. "This is not positive news. It's over."
An End to Diplomatic Planning
The next day Bush told his advisers he wanted to have a summit
with Blair to show solidarity. In part it was to fill the void.
War was certain, but the diplomatic circus hadn't ended. What
could he do? He did not want to just sit around. But Blair's
people were concerned about the prime minister leaving the
country for even eight hours because of the Margaret Thatcher
precedent: In 1990, she went abroad to a conference and was
ousted as party leader when she returned. Blair didn't want Bush
to give a speech or issue an ultimatum. He, Blair, had to pick
the right moment to call for a parliamentary vote. It was
Thursday, and any speech from Bush had to wait until at least
Monday.
Whatever would serve the British, Bush decided. And on Friday
there was another concession to Blair -- an announcement in the
Rose Garden of a "road map" for peace in the Middle
East that Blair thought should not be delayed until after the
Iraq issue was resolved.
The White House proposed a meeting on Bermuda. But that was too
far for Blair and too close to the United States. Another White
House proposal was for Bush to go to London. Blair's aides balked
-- the American president in London at that time would have been
a provocation for massive protests. They finally settled on the
Azores, a group of Portuguese islands in the North Atlantic
closer to London than to Washington.
The summit's purpose, White House press secretary Ari Fleischer
said, was "to review this diplomacy as it's brought to its
conclusion." It began on Sunday, March 16, and included
Bush, Blair, Spanish President Jose Maria Aznar and Portuguese
Prime Minister Jose Manuel Durao Barraso -- all supporters of a
war.
In a closed-door session, Bush told the others that he was going
to give a speech giving an ultimatum to Hussein to get out of
Iraq with his sons within 48 hours. "That's what I'm going
to do, okay?" Bush said. He wasn't consulting. He was
informing. "So everybody knows," he added.
They turned to the possibility that France, Russia or some other
Security Council member would introduce a counter-resolution to
delay "serious consequences" and force a vote. That
could be a real problem. All they could do, they agreed, was get
on the phone and head off the undecideds, get their commitment to
oppose a counter-resolution and vote no if necessary.
Blair stiffened. "If another country tried to introduce a
new resolution for the sole purpose of delaying us," the
prime minister said, "we'd have to regard that as a hostile
act diplomatically."
This brought them back to the French, the guiding force of delay.
"I'd be glad to veto something of theirs," Bush said.
"Really glad!"
The diplomatic planning was over. "You know," Bush
said, "we're going to, we have to keep planning for a future
postwar Iraq, and we all agree on the five basic principles.
Territorial integrity has to remain. We need immediate, we need
to be ready with humanitarian aid to get it in there immediately
to head off any food or displaced-persons crisis."
The diplomatic planning was over.
"You know," Bush said, "we're going to, we have to
keep planning for a future postwar Iraq, and we all agree on the
five basic principles. Territorial integrity has to remain. We
need immediate, we need to be ready with humanitarian aid to get
it in there immediately to head off any food or displaced-persons
crisis."
The United Nations would continue its oil-for-food program, Bush
said. "We have to build an international consensus for Iraq,
a new Iraq, at peace with its neighbors, and we'll go back to the
U.N. for another resolution after the war. The U.N. can help with
many issues but should not run the country."
He made it clear that the coalition would be in charge.
When the meeting broke up, Rice saw chief White House
speechwriter Michael Gerson, who had come with Bush on the
4,600-mile round trip to the Azores so they could work on the
ultimatum speech. "Do you have a copy of the speech?"
Rice asked, and she handed it to Blair.
Gerson was a little bug-eyed. It was about as closely held a
document as there might be. At the same time, Gerson realized
that it could have a tremendous impact not only on American
politics but also on the course of British politics because of
the impending vote of confidence in Parliament. Gerson noticed
that Campbell, Blair's communications and strategy adviser, was
reading the copy and jotting notes.
The British wanted the speech to be more conditional, with the
phrase or concept "if war comes" liberally sprinkled
throughout. Though it implied war, it should not be a war speech.
A kernel of hope for a peaceful solution had to remain.
Blair had to get home to tend to the politics of war and
rebellion in his party. White House Chief of Staff Andrew H. Card
Jr. noted that Blair had been filled with both resolve and angst.
It wasn't confident resolve. Rice thought it was very much
touch-and-go about Blair's future. As she stood watching the
British depart, she said, "Gee, I hope this isn't the last
time we see them."
On Air Force One, Bush and Rice agreed it was now just a matter
of managing the politics of the United Nations and not pulling
the plug before Blair had his vote in Parliament. Karen Hughes
and Dan Bartlett, the former and current communications
directors, joined them, and they went over the speech draft line
by line. The British suggestions were acceptable, and Gerson went
back on one of the plane's computers and carefully put in the
changes.
After Gerson was finished, he joined the president and all the
others who were about 10 minutes into the Mel Gibson movie
"Conspiracy Theory." Bush loudly summarized the plot,
and during the rest of the movie he made fun of it as fairly
predictable.
Blair's Day of Reckoning
In a 15-minute call the next day, Monday, March 17, Bush and
Blair, back in their respective capitals, coordinated efforts to
make sure there was no counter-resolution. They agreed that the
Russians would have to be talked to at various levels.
Blair said his prospects looked better, but it was still tough
for him right now. "I think I can win," Blair said.
"I'm concerned about the margin of victory. I don't want to
depend on Tory votes. I want to win my own party strong. I know
I'm not going to win them all, but I don't want the Tories to be
able to say without us, you would have lost, and I'm working hard
on the Labor Party to make sure I get a very clear solid majority
of the Labor votes."
Tuesday, March 18, was Blair's day of reckoning. Even some of his
leading critics called his one-hour speech in Parliament that day
one of his most effective and passionate.
"In this dilemma, no choice is perfect, no cause
ideal," Blair said. "But on this decision hangs the
fate of many things."
At 1:30 p.m., Bush called Blair to say, "Tremendous
speech."
"I know now I've got the votes to win the resolution,"
Blair said, "because the whip counters have been up all
night working away. And the only question is the margin, but I'm
confident."
They talked about the need to give Russia, France and Germany a
way back into the fold.
Bush had never paid such close attention to a debate or vote in a
foreign legislature as the one going on that day in the British
Parliament. "What's the vote count?" he had asked a
number of times during the day.
Finally, at 5:15 p.m. -- 10:15 p.m. London time -- Parliament
voted. Blair won by 396 to 217. Though he had lost a full third
of his own party's vote, the Tories -- and Britain -- had voted
for war.
U.S. Aimed For Hussein As
War Began
CIA Informants Told of His Suspected Whereabouts
On the day President Bush led the United States to war in Iraq,
he met with the National Security Council in the White House
Situation Room, linked by secure video with Gen. Tommy R. Franks
and nine of his senior commanders. It was the morning of
Wednesday, March 19, 2003.
Franks, who was at Prince Sultan air base in Saudi Arabia,
explained that each commander would brief the president.
"Do you have everything you need?" Bush asked Lt. Gen.
T. Michael "Buzz" Moseley, the Air Force commander who
was running the air operations out of Saudi Arabia. "Can you
win?"
"My command and control is all up," Moseley said.
"I've received and distributed the rules of engagement. I
have no issues. I am in place and ready." He was careful not
to promise outright victory. "I have everything we need to
win."
"I'm ready," said Lt. Gen. David D. McKiernan, the Army
ground commander. "We are moving into forward attack
positions. Our logistics are in place. We have everything we need
to win."
"Green across the board," said Vice Admiral Timothy J.
Keating.
Bush repeated his questions to each of the other commanders. The
answers were all affirmative, and got shorter each time.
"The rules of engagement and command and control are in
place," Franks said. "The force is ready to go, Mr.
President."
"For the peace of the world and the benefit and freedom of
the Iraqi people," Bush said, "I hereby give the order
to execute Operation Iraqi Freedom. May God bless the
troops."
"May God bless America," Franks replied.
"We're ready to go," the president said. "Let's
win it." He raised his hand in a salute to his commanders,
and then abruptly stood and turned before the others could jump
up. Tears welled up in his eyes, and in the eyes of some of the
others as Bush left the room. When he reached the Oval Office, he
went outside for a walk.
"It was emotional for me," Bush recalled in an
interview last December. "I prayed as I walked around the
circle. I prayed that our troops be safe, be protected by the
Almighty, that there be minimal loss of life." He prayed for
all who were to go into harm's way for the country.
"Going into this period, I was praying for strength to do
the Lord's will. . . . I'm surely not going to justify war based
upon God. Understand that. Nevertheless, in my case I pray that I
be as good a messenger of His will as possible. And then, of
course, I pray for personal strength and for forgiveness."
After his walk, the president made a series of secure phone calls
to leaders of coalition countries saying, in essence, "We're
launching!"
At this point, the war plan called for 48 hours of stealth
operations, with the first Special Operations teams crossing the
border from Jordan into western Iraq to stop any Scud missiles at
9 a.m. Eastern Time, 5 p.m. in Iraq. At the end of that period,
at 1 p.m. Washington time on Friday, March 21, nine hours of
"shock and awe" bombing and missile strikes would
begin, with the major ground incursion scheduled for that night.
The president would address the nation sometime Friday to
announce that military action had begun.
But there had been a new development that threw some of those
plans into doubt -- the opportunity, apparently, to kill Saddam
Hussein before the war really even started.
Bush had learned about it the day before, when CIA Director
George J. Tenet had come to the White House. He had been keeping
Bush updated on the ROCKSTARS, the network of informants inside
Iraq that the CIA had developed and cultivated since the previous
fall, and how they were getting the CIA closer to locating
Hussein. Now, he said, several ROCKSTARS were reporting with
increasing detail and granularity the possibility that Hussein or
his family was -- or soon would be -- at Dora Farm, a complex
southeast of Baghdad on the bank of the Tigris River.
At Bush's intelligence briefing that morning, Tenet said that he
might have something really good later on, but that he wasn't
going to say anything more. He didn't want to raise expectations
on the day the president was going to order the war to begin. It
was unusual for Tenet to be so vague, and White House Chief of
Staff Andrew H. Card Jr. noticed that Tenet was excited, almost
effervescent. Tenet was never undermotivated but this was
unusual, Card thought. Very unusual.
10:15 a.m. (6: 15 p.m. in Iraq)
In the mountainous Kurdish-controlled region of northern Iraq, a
man named Tim, the head of a CIA paramilitary team, had set up a
communications center about 10,000 feet up -- three 1970s
trailers and some old Quonset huts wrapped in plastic and tied
with ropes. They christened it Jonestown. Tim had 87 ROCKSTARS
out there, reporting on the Thuraya satellite phones he had given
them, a high-tech 7-by-7-foot screen displaying the exact
location of each call coming from inside Iraq. Their calls were
taken by two Kurdish brothers recruited by Tim, members of a
repressed religious group who had wanted to help the CIA and the
United States.
Tim had three of his case officers and two Special Forces guys up
there for security, basically living at Jonestown. They listened
to the reports coming in Arabic and then relayed them on a secure
radio down the mountain to Tim's base camp, where his team was
set up in a building painted lime green and known as
"Pistachio." They tried to turn the phoned-in reports
into intelligence reports as fast as possible for transmission to
CIA headquarters in Virginia. Tim always wanted more detail --
clarification, verification.
"Pistachio, Pistachio, this is Jonestown," came yet
another call from up the mountain. Jonestown had just received a
report from a ROCKSTAR -- a member of Hussein's security force,
the SSO, who ran part of the communications links Hussein used as
he moved between his palaces and other locations. The source said
he had just heard from another ROCKSTAR who had gone to Dora Farm
to help with communications and had noticed a significant
security detail. They were stocking food and supplies. It looked
like a family gathering.
Tim relayed this to Saul, head of the Iraq operations group, at
CIA headquarters, who reviewed the latest overhead imagery of
Baghdad. Lo and behold, under the palm trees at Dora Farm were 36
frickin' security vehicles! It was a huge number, not for one or
two people. The farm was used by Hussein's wife Sajida and Saul
knew that Hussein had used it.
About 10:30 a.m., Bush met with Homeland Security Secretary Tom
Ridge and New York City Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg.
"We're on the verge of war," the president said,
"and since New York City is a potential top target, it's
important we visit." He praised the city's efforts at
preparedness, but advised the mayor to focus on the main
potential targets of the terrorists. "Keep your eye on
tunnels, bridges and the Jewish community."
At 11:30 a.m. Washington time, a second Special Forces commando
team launched into Iraq, this one from Saudi Arabia.
1:05 p.m.
The president met with top advisers on energy matters in the
Roosevelt Room. The meeting included Vice President Cheney,
Secretary of State Colin L. Powell, national security adviser
Condoleezza Rice and Card. The questions focused on the
international flow of oil. What additional disruptions could take
place in the marketplace? Venezuela, which was in political
turmoil, had already drastically cut back production. Should the
president use the strategic petroleum reserve?
Robert McNally, an energy expert on the White House staff,
reported that crude oil prices had fallen from $37 a barrel to
$31. That was good news. A rapid increase in price would raise
costs for businesses and consumers across the board.
The Saudis had pledged to stabilize the crude oil market by
increasing output and putting crude into tankers that were
pre-positioned in the Caribbean or heading there.
When they looked at oil worldwide, McNally said, the crude
oversupply was 1.5 million to 1.9 million barrels a day. That
dramatic oversupply was driving down the price.
Energy Secretary Spencer Abraham said the Saudis would cover for
any loss of oil from Iraq by upping production to 10.5 million
barrels a day for 30 days -- an extraordinary pledge. In
December, the Saudis had been supplying only 8 million barrels a
day, and in February fewer than 9 million.
Commerce Secretary Donald L. Evans said that about two-thirds of
the Iraqi oil fields were located close together, and it was not
clear from intelligence how many had been wired to explode.
The president, displaying technical knowledge gained from his
earlier career in the oil business, said that if explosives were
rigged on the top of the well, the fire would be relatively easy
to extinguish, but if an explosion were set off deep down in the
pipes it could take forever to put out those fires. "If they
blow up their oil fields, it will be more than one month. If they
really blow them, it will be years."
Sometime after 12:30 p.m. (8:30 p.m. in Iraq), Tim received a
report that Rokan, a ROCKSTAR source who ran security at Dora
Farm, had seen Hussein, who had left the farm about eight hours
earlier to attend meetings but would be back to sleep at Dora
along with his sons Qusay and Uday. It was 100 percent sure that
Hussein "must" be returning. Tim knew that in the
context the "must" meant maybe, but he had to report
what he had been told.
At 1 p.m., at least 31 teams of Special Operations forces entered
Iraq in the west and north.
"They're on the ground; they're in," Card said in an
aside to the president.
It was almost too quiet. Bush and Card were eager to see whether
al-Jazeera or CNN or any news organization had picked up some
movement.
At 1:45 p.m., the president spoke with Spanish Prime Minister
Jose Maria Aznar for 20 minutes.
"We have to kind of speak in code," Bush said on the
secure line. "Things are changing. You may not see much but
it's a different pace."
Just after 2 p.m., there was still no leak.
Card checked with the Situation
Room.
"The Poles are in," he reported to the president.
"They've got the platform." A Polish special forces
team had gone in early and captured one of the key targets -- an
oil platform in the south.
Bush spoke briefly with the Polish President Aleksander
Kwasniewski.
"The Aussies are in," Card reported. An Australian
commando team had moved into the west.
3:15 p.m.
Tenet, CIA Deputy Director John E. McLaughlin, Saul and several
other CIA operatives had raced over to the Pentagon with Tim's
intelligence report and satellite photos to meet with Defense
Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld. Rumsfeld had been following the
ROCKSTAR intelligence and thought it merited the attention of the
president. The odds were that the group was not being
duplicitous; people were putting their lives at risk. But like
most intelligence, it was imperfect. Rumsfeld talked with Franks,
who thought Dora Farm was a good target, and the secretary asked
that he make sure they were ready to attack it.
Rumsfeld called Card. "We've got some developments, and I
want to come over and talk about them," he told Card, who
passed on the request to the president.
Tenet, meanwhile, phoned Stephen J. Hadley, the deputy national
security adviser. "I'm coming," Tenet said cryptically,
"I'm not going to say a word on the phone. I want to do it
with Don in the presence of the president. Nothing before
that."
Rumsfeld, McLaughlin, Tenet, Saul and two other CIA men soon
arrived in the Oval Office and went into the president's dining
room.
"We've got two guys close to Saddam," Tenet said. He
quickly summarized about the security guy, Rokan, at Dora, and
then the other ROCKSTAR who had gone down to help with
communications. Tenet produced satellite photos that showed the
location of the farm near Baghdad at a bend in the Tigris River.
There were several houses on the farm. "Saddam and the two
boys have been here, and might come back if they're still not
there." The CIA was in direct communication with both
sources.
Bush questioned them about the sources. Who were they? How good
were they?
Saul explained that a key to the ROCKSTAR network was the Special
Security Organization officer in communications who worked with
the two eyes-on sources at Dora. The SSO man's contacts and
recruits into the network had turned out to be very good. In
terms of Iraqi sources we are running, Saul told the president,
we judge him to be one of the better, more reliable sources.
"This is really good," the president said. "This
sounds good."
"Well," Saul said, "we'll never get 100 percent
confidence but the organization has proven reliable." At
this point, they had one source, Rokan, on the specifics of
Hussein's being there or about to return. "Right now,"
Saul said, "it's about 75 percent certain."
A decapitation strike on the top regime leaders now appeared
possible. They contemplated the impact of taking out Hussein and
his sons. Who would make the decisions inside Iraq? Everyone was
so used to directions from the highest level. The best-case
scenario was that it might even break the regime, make war
unnecessary. That was unlikely but possible.
What kind of weapons would you use? the president asked.
Gen. Richard B. Myers, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, who
had joined the group, said Tomahawk cruise missiles, and he
proposed a strike package of 15 to 17.
Bush was skeptical. He asked, Who is in which building? Where
would Hussein stay? Do the sons have kids? Where is the wife? Is
Hussein with his wife? Are we sure it is not just where he put
all of the kids to stay?
Waiting for Hussein
In northern Iraq, Tim threw a blazer over his long underwear and
put on his muddy boots. It was the ritual of respectability with
the Kurds. No matter how grubby, the brothers up at Jonestown
would be in coat and tie. He hopped in his Cherokee and drove
himself up the treacherous three miles from Pistachio to
Jonestown to be on the scene where the ROCKSTAR reports were
coming in. The atmosphere at Jonestown was frantic with the
brothers screaming, "Don't hang up! Stay on, stay on the
phone! Don't hang up!" Click. Tim decided the best thing to
do was scream back at them.
"The fate of your nation hangs on you," Tim yelled,
"and I'm going to pull it all away from you, and if you let
me down now, you're not going to get the seat at the table in a
new Iraqi government."
The principal source phoned in a report cobbled together from
what his two subsources at Dora Farm were telling him: Hussein's
sons were at the farm for sure, and Hussein was expected back
about 2:30 a.m. or 3 a.m. Iraqi time. The sources on the scene
also reported details about the houses. Additionally there was a
manzul on the compound, the report said. Manzul could be
translated as "place of refuge" or "bunker."
Tim chose bunker. The report provided some details about the
bunker -- distances from the main houses, and its thickness in so
many meters of concrete under so many meters of earth. Tim
frantically took this and sent back to CIA headquarters a flash
message summarizing the information.
The president had more questions. "Is it going to disrupt
Tommy's plan?" he asked. They had spent more than a year on
that plan. What would be the impact? Would it blow the whole
element of surprise? The Special Operations forces that had gone
in already were supposed to be covert. Would this expose them?
"Go ask Tommy," he directed Rumsfeld.
Myers eventually reached Franks.
"What do you think about taking a shot at this Dora Farm
target?" Myers asked.
Franks had been watching the time-sensitive targets carefully and
he had known the night before that the CIA had been getting
closer to Hussein, perhaps at Dora Farm. It looked like a target
for a Tomahawk cruise missile, and Franks had ordered the Navy to
program some missiles on the target. But it was still during the
48-hour ultimatum period the president had given Hussein and his
sons to leave. Franks felt pretty strongly, and had counseled
Rumsfeld, that they not take a shot during that period. It was a
kind of grace period.
Can you do it in two hours? Myers asked next.
Franks said they could. The Tomahawks were ready to go.
Sometime after 4 p.m.
The latest ROCKSTAR report arrived in the Situation Room and was
taken immediately to the Oval Office.
"They say they're with him right now! Both of the sons are
there," Tenet said. Their wives were there. The families
were there also. Hussein was expected back at 2:30 a.m. to 3 a.m.
Iraq time -- in less than two hours. There was a bunker and one
of the ROCKSTARS had paced off where it was, had gone inside and
taken rough measurements.
Hadley asked Saul, "Can you show me where the bunker
is?" Saul wasn't sure, but they took the overhead photos and
Hadley tried to draw a sketch. McLaughlin was soon doing an
improved amateur engineer drawing.
Powell was the only principal missing, and about 5:15 p.m. the
president told Rice, "You better call Colin."
"Colin, get to the White House!" she said, reaching
Powell at the State Department. She was abrupt and offered no
explanation. When Powell arrived in minutes, they summarized for
him. "If we've got a chance to decapitate them, it's worth
it," he finally said.
Rumsfeld strongly recommended a strike, and Cheney agreed, though
he seemed to be holding back.
Bush filled the time with questions, at one point asking: Were
they really sure what they were looking at was what they thought
they were looking at?
"It's as good as it gets," Tenet said. "I can't
give you 100 percent assurance, but this is as good as it
gets."
Bush was still worrying about the women and children. This could
be a kind of baby milk factory, he said, recalling an incident
from the 1991 Persian Gulf War when the Iraqis had claimed a
suspected biological weapons plant that was bombed was really for
the production of baby milk. "They would bring out dead
women and children," Bush said, "and the first pictures
would be of civilian casualties on a massive scale of some
kind."
Could Iraq use this as a public relations exercise? he asked. It
could engender sympathy for Hussein. Dead babies, children and
women would be a nightmare. That sure would get things off on the
wrong foot.
Rumsfeld and Myers said it probably didn't matter what they hit
in the first strike, because the Iraqi propaganda machine was
going to say that the United States killed a number of women and
children anyway. And if necessary the Iraqis would execute women
and children and say the United States did it.
That was indeed the downside. But the others -- Cheney, Rumsfeld,
Tenet, even Powell -- seemed taken with the upside, a shortcut to
victory.
Myers raised a serious problem. If there were a bunker at the
Dora compound as they now suspected, the cruise missiles would
not penetrate. They would need the bunker-busting 2,000-pound
bombs to get that deep. Myers was sent off to talk to Franks.
For a moment, the group weighed the downsides. They had promised
to defend Israel, and the full defense of Israel was not ready.
What were the other consequences? Suppose the Iraqis used a
strike as a pretext to set the oil wells ablaze? Suppose they
fired Scud missiles into Israel or Saudi Arabia? The consequences
of an early attack were immense. The plan called for the air
campaign to begin in two days.
Bush went around the room and asked: Would you do it?
"I would do it, Mr.
President," Card said. It was too good a chance not to take.
Rumsfeld, too, was strongly in favor.
Powell thought it was a hell of a lot of very specific
information that seemed not bad, though it was a little curious
that the CIA sources on the other end of the satellite phones
could have acquired so much.
"If we've got a chance to decapitate them, it's worth
it," Powell recommended again.
Rice and Hadley had some more questions about the sources, but
both favored an attack.
Myers reached Franks on a secure phone. Could he load up a
stealth fighter with a pair of EGBU-27 bombs, the bunker-busters,
for the attack?
"Absolutely not," Franks said. "We don't have the
F-117 ready to go." The F-117A Nighthawk, the stealth
single-seat fighter jet, typically carried two of the bombs when
fully loaded.
Franks checked further. The Air Force had been following the
intelligence and the night before had readied one F-117. The Air
Force squadron in Qatar had received word that day that the bombs
could be dropped in pairs safely, though it had never been tried
before.
Franks asked what the probability was of a single F-117 getting
through and delivering its pair of bombs. Though stealthy and
radar-evading, the F-117 would have to go in before the
suppression of Iraqi air defense, weak as that was. The plane
would be going in cold. The answer came back that the Air Force
could only say there was a 50 percent chance of success.
Prepare two bombers, Franks ordered, figuring that would improve
the chances.
In Qatar, the Air Force squadron was able to load a second F-117.
Franks sent word to the Oval Office that it would be possible,
but that he needed a final decision to go by about 7:15 p.m. in
order to get the F-117s in and out of Iraqi airspace well before
dawn.
Rumsfeld, Myers and CIA men were running in and out of the Oval
Office to find secure phones at West Wing locations. Card was
concerned that the window of opportunity was closing. Did they
really understand the intelligence? Was it necessary to change
the weapons? Myers was trying to find out how long it would take
the F-117s to be loaded, take off, then fly from Doha to Baghdad
and back. How many tankers do they have to have to refuel the
planes?
Another question arose. If it was approved, should the president
go on television that night and make his speech announcing the
beginning of the war -- a speech now scheduled for Friday?
"Look, this is an ongoing operation," Cheney said.
"We didn't announce that the Special Forces were going in.
We didn't announce the Poles were taking over the platform. We
didn't announce the Australians were heading toward the dam. We
don't have to announce it yet. You don't announce it until you
are ready to announce it."
Rumsfeld seemed to half agree. "If someone should go, maybe
it should be me," he said, but he then added, indicating
Bush, "Or maybe it could be you."
Powell raised the CNN effect. The attack would be seen instantly.
Reporters stationed at the Rashid Hotel in Baghdad were close
enough possibly to see it or hear it. Dozens of cruise missiles
and bunker-buster bombs. The media were spring-loaded to
proclaim, "It started! It started!" Antiaircraft fire
and tracers would be flying all around. The war was going to
begin with this event.
"If lives are in jeopardy," the president said,
"I've got to go announce it."
Cheney reminded him that lives were already in danger and that
there had been no announcement.
Should he wait until the next morning? the president asked. That
would give Franks an additional 12 hours before any announcement.
Bush called in his two main communications advisers, Karen Hughes
and Dan Bartlett, to the Oval Office. He told Saul to sum up the
intelligence.
Then, the president said he was probably going to order the
attack. "How do we do this?" he asked Hughes and
Bartlett. "Do I go on television?" Should he inform the
public before, during or after? Should the secretary of defense
do it? Everyone turned to Hughes. They knew how much Bush relied
on her.
"No, you need to do it, Mr. President," she said.
"The American people shouldn't hear it from the press; they
shouldn't hear it from somebody else. They should hear it from
you. And you should tell them what and why." If they hit
civilians or women and children, the president had to be ahead of
the curve. She added her trademark observation, "We can't
sort of be catching up."
Bartlett agreed with Hughes, but Cheney still had reservations.
What would this mean for Israel, Turkey, Saudi Arabia? Do we have
our defenses ready for Israel? Tommy's plan has a defense, but
the plan wasn't fully implemented yet.
Powell could not understand that they would start a war and not
get out front with a presidential announcement.
"I promised people I'd let them know when the war
begins," Bush said. "And if lives -- the war is
beginning tonight, lives will be in jeopardy, I have to tell the
American people that I've committed American forces to war."
Cheney didn't seem happy.
"They have to hear it from me," Bush said. "I'm
doing it." This would be starting the war, he said.
"Let's not kid ourselves."
6 p.m.
Card called Bush speechwriter Michael Gerson. "Is it
ready?" Card asked. There was only one speech left to give.
"In about five minutes I can have it ready," Gerson
said.
"I want you to meet me outside the Oval Office at 6:30 with
several copies of the speech."
Gerson went down to the Oval Office and sat in one of the two
chairs outside.
Card soon emerged. "We'll be with you soon enough. Just
wait," he told him. Card took the copies of the speech,
leaving Gerson to cool his heels. Obviously something was up, but
Gerson had no idea what. Tenet and his people were running in and
out making secure calls.
Inside the Oval Office, the president went around the room again,
asking if all the principals agreed, almost pushing each to the
wall. They did.
Bush turned to Saul. "Well, what do you think?"
Saul's head was spinning. He had never been involved in a
discussion like this, let alone been asked his opinion. He was
worried about the pilots of the F-117s. His intelligence was now
going to put American lives directly at risk. The planes would be
going in with no electronic countermeasures, no fighter escort,
no advance suppression of Iraqi air defense. "I have to
apologize that we have to present you with this very tough
decision," Saul said to the president. "I really feel
sorry for you having to make it."
"Don't," Bush said. "That's what I do. I'll make
the decision."
"Well, sir," Saul said, "then I would say
launch."
The president kicked everyone out of the Oval Office but Cheney.
What do you think, Dick?
"This is the best intelligence we've had yet on where
Saddam's located," Cheney replied. "If we get him, it
may save a lot of lives and shorten the war. And even if we
don't, we're going to rattle his cage pretty seriously, and maybe
disrupt the chain of command. That's well worth the effort in and
of itself." Now he was unequivocal. "I think we ought
to go for it."
12 p.m.
The others came back in. Finally, the president said, "Let's
go." It was three minutes before Franks's deadline.
Powell noted silently that things didn't really get decided until
the president had met with Cheney alone.
Myers went to the secure phone to inform Franks.
Rumsfeld emerged from the Oval Office and saw Gerson. "I was
just butchering your speech," he said.
The president called out, "Gerson, come on in." Hughes
and Bartlett were standing there.
"We're going after them," Bush explained.
"I don't understand," Gerson said.
"The intelligence is good," Bush replied, explaining
that it showed they had a shot at Hussein and his sons.
"Let's hope we're right," he added, choking up.
Rumsfeld's "butchery" of the speech was simple. He
wanted the president to say that this was the "early
stages" of military operations, and again in the second
paragraph refer to the "opening stages" of war.
"I want to see you over in the residence when you're
ready," Bush said to Gerson and Hughes, directing that the
changes be made.
The two went up to Gerson's second-floor office and made the
changes in a few minutes. Gerson was glad they were going to
restore a line that had been cut from Monday's ultimatum speech.
Referring to Hussein and his alleged weapons of mass destruction,
the line now read: "We meet that threat now, with our Army,
Air Force, Navy, Coast Guard and Marines so that we do not have
to meet it later with armies of firefighters and police and
doctors on the streets of our cities." Gerson thought it was
the most vivid way to put it. The implication of avoiding another
9/11 would be clear.
Rumsfeld read the speech word for word to Franks over a secure
phone to make sure he had no objections or suggestions. He had
none.
Rice placed a quick call at 7:30 p.m. to Israeli Finance Minister
Binyamin Netanyahu about another matter. He said he already knew
about the war and wished it would be fast and
"bloodless."
She woke up David Manning, the British national security adviser.
"David, there's a little change in plans. And I'm sorry to
say this, but I think you better wake the prime minister and tell
him."
The President Prepares
Bush went to the residence. Card sat with him in the Yellow Room.
Are you comfortable? the chief of staff asked. Are you ready to
give the speech? He wanted to separate the two -- the decision to
go after Hussein and the speech.
Yes, the president said, he was ready on both counts. Though he
had asked all in the war cabinet, including Card, if they would
do this, and each had said yes, he asked again. "You would
do this?"
"Yes," Card said, "this is the right thing to do.
Absolutely. Take this chance."
How long have the F-117s been up? the president asked. When do
they get there?
The next report said they were in Iraqi airspace. There would be
no more preliminary reports because they would be on radio
silence over Iraq.
Hughes, Bartlett and Gerson went over to the residence. Unsure
whether the president wanted to see them or just receive the
speech, they asked the usher to check. If Bush was having dinner,
they did not want to interrupt. The usher soon came back and
escorted them up to the Treaty Room, Bush's private office.
Gerson thought Bush was subdued and a little pale. For the first
time he looked to Gerson a little bit burdened by all of this.
The president took the speech and began to read it aloud:
"My fellow citizens, at this hour . . .
"American and coalition forces are in the early stages of
military operations to disarm Iraq, to free its people and to
defend the world from grave danger."
He read through the 10 paragraphs and said it was fine. He had no
changes. He walked them to the elevator.
Quietly, as if to reassure himself, Bush said again, "The
intelligence is good."
'God Help Us All'
Rice called Prince Bandar bin Sultan, the Saudi ambassador.
"Can I see you at 7:45?" she asked.
"Condi," Bandar said, "we have to stop meeting
like this -- this hour. People will talk."
Normally any meeting after 6:30 p.m. was a kind of code word,
meaning that Bandar would be seeing the president. Bandar had
booked an entire small Arabian restaurant in Georgetown that
night to dine with his wife, family and some friends. He told his
wife to go ahead. He arrived in the West Wing lobby and noticed a
photographer. Odd. When he was finally ushered in at 8:28 p.m.,
Rice stepped to her outer office to greet him. Flash!
Bandar jumped, saying, "I hope he works for you."
"Yes, yes, don't worry."
The photographer snapped again as they were about to sit down,
and a third time after they sat.
"The president has " Rice began.
" . . . asked me to tell you," Bandar interrupted,
completing her sentence, "that we are going to war."
It was obvious -- the ultimatum's expiration and the
photographer. "I've been meeting you in this office for two
years and I've never had a photographer in here. I'm not retiring
to take goodbye photos. You're not retiring."
About 9 p.m., hell will break loose, Rice said. "And your
friend, the president, insisted that you be informed
immediately."
"Where is the president now?" Bandar asked.
"He is having dinner right now with the first lady and then
he decided he wants to be alone."
"Tell him he will be in our prayers and hearts," Bandar
said. "God help us all."
Rice's phone rang at 8:29 p.m.
"Yes, yes, Mr. President," she said. "No, I told
him. . . . He's here. . . . Yes, he is with me. I told him. Well,
he said you're in his prayers."
"He said thank you," Rice reported after hanging up.
"Just keep praying."
He had arranged a code to alert Crown Prince Abdullah if he
learned early -- a reference to the Roda, an oasis outside
Riyadh.
"Tonight the forecast is there will be heavy rain in the
Roda," Bandar said from his car phone to Saudi Arabia.
"Oh, I see," the crown prince said. "I see. Are
you sure?"
"I am very sure," he replied, adding that the Americans
had great capabilities, satellites and so forth, to predict the
weather.
"Tell me again."
Bandar repeated.
The crown prince took a deep breath. "May God decide what is
good for all of us." Then he asked loudly, "Do you know
how soon the storm is going to hit?"
"Sir," Bandar said, potentially blowing operational
security if any foreign embassy or anyone else with the
capability was listening in, "I don't know, but watch
TV."
Preparing to Inform the Nation
In his interview last December, Bush recalled the moment.
"It's been a very long day. I get upstairs, and I can't
sleep. Because I've got about an hour and a half now." He
didn't want to speak until the bombers were off their targets.
"I was trying to take a little nap."
Once more, he called Rice. No news.
He tried to sleep or read or find something to do and couldn't so
he called Rice again.
"Mr. President, we've just got a report from the person on
the ground. A convoy has pulled into the complex."
"Is that convoy full of kids?" Bush asked. It hit him
that there was no turning back now. The bombers were going in
first, followed immediately by 36 cruise missiles. They had
doubled the Tomahawk attack package. The Tomahawk cruise
missiles, which had been launched to the Dora Farm target more
than an hour earlier, had no self-destruct mechanism so they were
going in no matter what.
"No," Rice replied, "he thinks that it looks like
the kind of convoy that would bring Saddam Hussein."
About an hour later, the president came down to the Oval Office
and did a read-through, then went to his study off the Oval
Office.
Normally at the end of the day press secretary Ari Fleischer
would put a "lid" on, telling the White House reporters
that there would be no more news that night. But Fleischer knew
that the extraordinarily long Oval Office meeting meant
something, especially with all the running around by the
principals and the presence of even a few unfamiliar faces. So he
was going to be careful. Finally, Card took Fleischer into his
corner office.
It's going to start tonight, Card said. These are the early
stages. We have a target of opportunity and are sending a stealth
fighter to go after it.
"Are we sending anything else in?"
"I told you everything you need to know," Card replied.
The attack would be south of Baghdad. Iraqi antiaircraft
batteries would soon be going off.
Rice, Card, Bartlett and Fleischer gathered around the TV in
Rice's office. At 9:30 p.m. reports came that air raid sirens had
gone off in Baghdad. Antiaircraft fire soon followed.
"Go out," Rice told Fleischer.
Fleischer was at the podium at 9:45: "The opening stages of
the disarmament of the Iraqi regime have begun. The president
will address the nation at 10:15."
Myers reported to Hadley that the F-117s had successfully dropped
their bombs, but the pilots were not yet out of hostile
territory. Hadley went to the study off the Oval Office where the
president was getting his makeup, and relayed the report to Bush
and Rice.
"Let's pray for the pilots," Bush said.
10:16 p.m.
The president appeared on television, the stock flags and family
photos in the background. He said the "early stages" of
the military campaign against Hussein had begun, without offering
any details. "More than 35 countries are giving crucial
support," he said. "A campaign on the harsh terrain of
a nation as large as California could be longer and more
difficult than some predict." It was a time of "grave
danger" and "peril."
"Our forces will be coming home as soon as their work is
done," he said. "This will not be a campaign of
half-measures."
When he was done, he asked Rice how the speech had gone. One of
the better ones, she told him.
Hadley called Myers, who reported about 11 p.m. that the pilots
were out of hostile airspace and on the approach to land. Rice
called the president.
"The pilots are out of harm's way," she said.
"Well, thank God for that."
A few minutes before midnight in Washington (8 a.m. Iraqi time),
Tim sent a report saying that the principal ROCKSTAR reported
that Hussein and his sons were at Dora Farm when the bombs and
missiles hit, but he did not know their status. Tim did not want
to report again until he was pretty sure they had gotten Hussein.
Before dawn in Washington (about noon in Iraq), he sent another
cable. Again he had to report what the ROCKSTARS said, but he was
uncertain because he was just getting snatches from ROCKSTARS
fleeing the scene. Rokan, their source, had been killed by a
cruise missile. One of Hussein's sons, it was unclear which, had
come out shouting, "We've been betrayed" and shot
another of the ROCKSTARS in the knee. The other son had emerged
from the rubble bloody and disoriented but it wasn't clear
whether it was his blood or someone else's. Hussein had been
injured, according to a ROCKSTAR witness, and had to be dug out
of the rubble. He was blue. He was gray. He was being given
oxygen. He had been put on a stretcher and loaded into the back
of an ambulance, which then did not move for half an hour before
departing the farm across a bridge.
About 4:30 a.m. Tenet called the Situation Room and told the duty
officer, "Tell the president we got the son of a
bitch."
They didn't wake the president. And by the time Bush arrived at
the Oval Office about 6:30 a.m. Thursday, March 20, they weren't
so sure. It looked as though Hussein may have survived.
Epilogue
On March 24, 2003, five days after the start of the war, Tim made
his way down to Dora Farm. It looked like the remnants of a flea
market, people were still carting stuff away. There were craters
and clearly the place had been attacked. He searched everywhere.
There was no bunker or any hint of one. He found a subterranean
pantry for food storage attached to the main house. Perhaps that
was what his ROCKSTAR agents had been referring to. It was
baffling and mysterious. Was it possible that manzul was neither
a place of refuge nor a bunker, but a pantry?
Tim eventually tracked down some of the ROCKSTAR agents who had
reported that night. Two said their wives had been captured by
Hussein's agents and had their fingernails pulled out. Another
maintained that his house had been bulldozed. There was some
evidence to support these claims, but Tim was unsure.
Soon Tim was reassigned to CIA headquarters to work undercover on
other issues. Saul and other superiors asked him and the team
members to put down the sequence of events of the day and night
of March 19 to 20, 2003. They wanted a very briefable, immaculate
package. The more Tim searched his memory and the few documents,
he realized that much was cloudy. Everyone had been stressed. The
ROCKSTARS on the ground had not wanted to disappoint, and had
obviously been worried about being captured or killed.
Tim made a series of efforts to write down in a meaningful way
what had happened. He tried a version. Did he have 40 percent? Or
62 percent? Or 83 percent? he wondered. What percentage of the
truth was available? What had slipped away? What had been untrue?
He tried several more times. It wasn't black or white, and it
certainly wasn't a straight line. Was he getting closer or
further from the truth?
He never produced a definitive version. The biggest unanswered
question was whether Saddam Hussein and his entourage had really
been there that night.